Hema Feel Vindicated by Lubanga Trial Crisis
Supporters of militia leader cite his chaotic trial as proof that he should never been indicted.
Hema Feel Vindicated by Lubanga Trial Crisis
Supporters of militia leader cite his chaotic trial as proof that he should never been indicted.
Inside a Bunia neighborhood mud hut where one can buy a bowl of mandro, a murky homemade beer, customers say the International Criminal Court, ICC, was wrong to prosecute Thomas Lubanga.
Many in the hut in Mudzi-pela – on the side of Bunia that is almost wholly occupied by the Hema ethnic group to which Lubanga belongs – believe the delays and problems with the trial are a sign that the case was weak from the outset.
“[This] shows that the ICC cannot take control of the case. We can’t understand why they have postponed it so many times,” said one patron, who, along with others here, see Lubanga as a hero not a villain.
The trial was supposed to start on June 23, but judges have postponed it after concluding that the prosecution had withheld a “significant” body of evidence from the defence. They consider the breach so serious that they will meet on June 24 to decide whether Lubanga should be released and dismiss the case against him.
Lubanga, who is being held in The Hague, has been charged with recruiting children under the age of 15 to become fighters for his militia, the military wing of his political party, the Union of Patriotic Congolese, UPC.
Vicious clashes between the Lendu and Hema in the Ituri region of northeastern Democratic Republic of the Congo, DRC, grew out of a civil conflict that broke out in the region more than ten years ago.
The decade of war, which has resulted in the deaths of more than five million people, according to recent reports, saw the toppling of the two regimes and the spawning of many ethnic-based rival militia groups in the eastern Congo.
The Ituri region has been the focus of ICC investigations since 2003, and has resulted in the arrest of four Congolese, including Lubanga, Germain Katanga, Matthieu Ngudjolo, and Jean Pierre Bemba, a senator and former presidential candidate. Militia leader Bosco Ntaganda has also been indicted, but he is still at large in eastern Congo.
Lubanga’s trial – which was the first to be prosecuted by the ICC – was originally scheduled to begin on March 31.
Various reasons have been given for the delays, including the failure of prosecutors to disclose to the defence all its evidence and the identities of witnesses testifying against the accused.
To people in Mudzi-pela, Lubanga is a saviour who defended them during the decade-long civil war.
“Thomas came to our rescue,” said one woman. “We were running for our lives with babies in our arms. He came to help.”
She pointed to the dirt road outside the hut where she said five people had been killed.
“People were trying to kill us. They were Lendu,” said another woman. “Thomas [Lubanga] helped us so much.”
The repeated stays in the Lubanga proceedings have drawn accusations in the region that a case should never have been brought against him.
“The [ICC is] telling lies,” said one man, adding that many Hema orphans had little option but to become fighters. “Imagine the [Lendu] come and kill your family. It’s better to be a child soldier. Children were given a way of protecting themselves.”
Many Hema locals believe that government forces were mostly to blame for the killings in the neighbourhood and that Lubanga was never more than a minor actor in the conflict.
“They [the ICC] don’t understand what happened here. The ICC didn’t get all the information. The ICC is unable to judge Thomas Lubanga. He should be brought back here,” said another man.
Locals want more high-level suspects indicted for their role in the conflict, said Alfred Nbugu, a Catholic priest who works with the Caritas organisation in Bunia.
Many Hema, he said, don’t understand how recruitment of child soldiers has taken precedence over mass killings of innocent civilians, “For local people, they want to see those who killed 60,000 people in the community arrested.
“When they arrest those in government with power, not just the small fish, then people will begin to trust the ICC. The ICC has a challenge to explain its approach.”
On the Lendu side of Bunia, in the Kindia neighborhood, community leader Ernest Peke sat in front of his house on the edge of town and pointed to the distant hill where militias were trained and frequently overran the area.
“There was a big house here. It was all destroyed,” he said.
He lays blame for much of the killings over the past decade on forces from neighbouring Uganda and Rwanda, whose armies occupied the region from 1998 to 2003.
Peke said the recruitment of child soldiers was widely known and was a common practice. “[Lots of] children lost their parents, so it was easy for them to join those groups,” he said.
The Lendu community, he went on, is deeply frustrated with the constant delays in the Lubanga trial.
“[The trial] should be done as quickly as possible,” said Peke. “If the ICC has no evidence, then they should release him. Just keeping him in jail is not good for anybody.”
Peter Eichstaedt is IWPR’s Africa Editor.
Many in the hut in Mudzi-pela – on the side of Bunia that is almost wholly occupied by the Hema ethnic group to which Lubanga belongs – believe the delays and problems with the trial are a sign that the case was weak from the outset.
“[This] shows that the ICC cannot take control of the case. We can’t understand why they have postponed it so many times,” said one patron, who, along with others here, see Lubanga as a hero not a villain.
The trial was supposed to start on June 23, but judges have postponed it after concluding that the prosecution had withheld a “significant” body of evidence from the defence. They consider the breach so serious that they will meet on June 24 to decide whether Lubanga should be released and dismiss the case against him.
Lubanga, who is being held in The Hague, has been charged with recruiting children under the age of 15 to become fighters for his militia, the military wing of his political party, the Union of Patriotic Congolese, UPC.
Vicious clashes between the Lendu and Hema in the Ituri region of northeastern Democratic Republic of the Congo, DRC, grew out of a civil conflict that broke out in the region more than ten years ago.
The decade of war, which has resulted in the deaths of more than five million people, according to recent reports, saw the toppling of the two regimes and the spawning of many ethnic-based rival militia groups in the eastern Congo.
The Ituri region has been the focus of ICC investigations since 2003, and has resulted in the arrest of four Congolese, including Lubanga, Germain Katanga, Matthieu Ngudjolo, and Jean Pierre Bemba, a senator and former presidential candidate. Militia leader Bosco Ntaganda has also been indicted, but he is still at large in eastern Congo.
Lubanga’s trial – which was the first to be prosecuted by the ICC – was originally scheduled to begin on March 31.
Various reasons have been given for the delays, including the failure of prosecutors to disclose to the defence all its evidence and the identities of witnesses testifying against the accused.
To people in Mudzi-pela, Lubanga is a saviour who defended them during the decade-long civil war.
“Thomas came to our rescue,” said one woman. “We were running for our lives with babies in our arms. He came to help.”
She pointed to the dirt road outside the hut where she said five people had been killed.
“People were trying to kill us. They were Lendu,” said another woman. “Thomas [Lubanga] helped us so much.”
The repeated stays in the Lubanga proceedings have drawn accusations in the region that a case should never have been brought against him.
“The [ICC is] telling lies,” said one man, adding that many Hema orphans had little option but to become fighters. “Imagine the [Lendu] come and kill your family. It’s better to be a child soldier. Children were given a way of protecting themselves.”
Many Hema locals believe that government forces were mostly to blame for the killings in the neighbourhood and that Lubanga was never more than a minor actor in the conflict.
“They [the ICC] don’t understand what happened here. The ICC didn’t get all the information. The ICC is unable to judge Thomas Lubanga. He should be brought back here,” said another man.
Locals want more high-level suspects indicted for their role in the conflict, said Alfred Nbugu, a Catholic priest who works with the Caritas organisation in Bunia.
Many Hema, he said, don’t understand how recruitment of child soldiers has taken precedence over mass killings of innocent civilians, “For local people, they want to see those who killed 60,000 people in the community arrested.
“When they arrest those in government with power, not just the small fish, then people will begin to trust the ICC. The ICC has a challenge to explain its approach.”
On the Lendu side of Bunia, in the Kindia neighborhood, community leader Ernest Peke sat in front of his house on the edge of town and pointed to the distant hill where militias were trained and frequently overran the area.
“There was a big house here. It was all destroyed,” he said.
He lays blame for much of the killings over the past decade on forces from neighbouring Uganda and Rwanda, whose armies occupied the region from 1998 to 2003.
Peke said the recruitment of child soldiers was widely known and was a common practice. “[Lots of] children lost their parents, so it was easy for them to join those groups,” he said.
The Lendu community, he went on, is deeply frustrated with the constant delays in the Lubanga trial.
“[The trial] should be done as quickly as possible,” said Peke. “If the ICC has no evidence, then they should release him. Just keeping him in jail is not good for anybody.”
Peter Eichstaedt is IWPR’s Africa Editor.
